Introduction:
The term “Zion” can refer to the Temple
Mount, as when the Prophet Jeremiah mourned
over the destroyed Temple, he said, “For
this our heart was faint...for Mount Zion
which lies desolate; foxes prowl over it”
(Lamentations 5:18). Although the mountain
of the Temple is Mount Moriah, the prophet
gives it the poetic name, “Mount Zion.”
(Talmud, Makos 24b)
”Zion” also refers to Jerusalem, as the
Prophet Isaiah proclaimed to Jerusalem the
following Divine message: “And they shall
call you the city of the Compassionate One,
Zion of the Holy One of Israel” (Isaiah
60:14).
In addition, “Zion” refers to the Land of
Israel, as it is written, “For the
Compassionate One will comfort Zion, He will
comfort all her ruins; He will make her
wilderness like Eden, and her wasteland like
a garden of the Compassionate One; joy and
gladness will be found there, thanksgiving
and the sound of music” (Isaiah 51:3).
Dear Friends,
It is written in the Book of Psalms: “And of
Zion it shall be said ‘this person and that
person was born in her’ ” (Psalm 87:5). The
word “person” is repeated twice in this
verse, and the Talmud states that this
repetition comes to teach us that both the
one who was physically born in Zion and the
one in exile who aspires to see Zion are
considered to be Zion's children. Each one
was “born in her” (Kesuvos 75a).
Rabbi Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld cited this
explanation of the Talmud in a halachic
response to a question that came to him
during the period when the British ruled
over Eretz Yisrael – the Land of Israel. The
British government had instituted a quota
which severely limited the number of Jews
that could immigrate to Eretz Yisrael;
however, the quota restrictions did not
apply to someone from abroad who was born in
Eretz Yisrael. A Jewish man, who was born in
the diaspora, had applied for an immigration
certificate for Eretz Yisrael, and Rabbi
Yosef Chaim was asked: “Could someone
declare in court that this man was born in
Eretz Yisrael, in order to circumvent the
quota restrictions?” Rabbi Yosef Chaim was
scrupulously truthful, and he constantly
exhorted others to refrain from anything
dishonest; nevertheless, in this case, he
replied:
“It is certainly permissible, and even
obligatory, to do so. There is nothing
dishonest about it. The Talmud states
explicitly on the verse, ‘And of Zion it
shall be said this person and that person
was born in her’ - both one who was born in
her and one who aspires to see her. From
this we can derive that any Jew who aspires
to live in Eretz Yisrael is considered as if
he was born there. It is therefore permitted
to testify in court regarding this man who
has submitted an application to enter Eretz
Yisrael that he was born there. All who
yearn to come to Zion are indeed natives of
Zion.”
The story of Rav Yosef Chaim’s halachic
decision had a profound effect on me. When
people ask me where I was born, I no longer
say that I was born in Brooklyn, New York
City; instead, I say that I grew up in New
York City. And if they insist on knowing
where I was born, I tell them that I was
born in Zion, but for some strange reason, I
found myself as a baby in Brooklyn!
As we have discussed in this series, we were
“born” in Zion not just for our sake, but
for the sake of the world. Through
fulfilling the holistic halacha of the
Torah, we are to develop in Zion a model
society which can also serve as a universal
spiritual center when, “the mountain of
the Temple of the Compassionate One will be
firmly established as the head of the
mountains, exalted above the hills, and all
the nations will stream to it” (Isaiah 2:2).
Shalom,
Yosef ben Shlomo Hakohen (See below)
Related Comments:
1. Rav Yosef Chaim’s halachic decision
helped me to appreciate a statement of
Shmuel Agnon, an Israeli writer who was
committed to the halacha of the Torah path,
and whose literature and poetry drew on our
Torah sources, including halachic writings.
In 1966, he won the Nobel prize for
literature, and in his acceptance speech at
the Nobel banquet in Stockholm, he said:
“As a result of the historic catastrophe in
which Titus of Rome destroyed Jerusalem and
Israel was exiled from its land, I was born
in one of the cities of the Exile. But
always I regarded myself as one who was born
in Jerusalem.”
2. Shmuel Agnon, at the conclusion of his
acceptance speech for the Nobel prize,
offered the following prayer: “May a
redeemer come to Zion, may the earth be
filled with knowledge and eternal joy for
all who dwell therein, and may they enjoy
much peace. May all this be God's will.
Amen.” This statement was inspired by
various messianic prophecies which indicate
that our physical and spiritual renewal in
Zion is destined to benefit the entire
world. For example, after our renewal in
Zion, “the earth will be filled with
knowledge of the Compassionate One” (Isaiah
11:9), and “nation shall not lift up sword
against nation” (Isaiah 2:4).
3. In the following prophecy of Isaiah, the
Compassionate One comforts Zion, who is
mourning for her lost children, and He
promises her that there will come the day
when the nations of the world will help her
children to return home:
“Behold I will raise My hand toward nations,
and I will hoist my banner towards peoples,
and they will bring your sons in their arms,
and your daughters will be carried on their
shoulders.” (Isaiah 49:22)
4. According to Jewish tradition, the
nations of the world will merit to become
the spiritual children of Zion during the
messianic age. One source for this teaching
is found in the Song of Songs - an
allegorical love poem which describes the
relationship between the Compassionate One
and Israel. In this allegorical poem, there
is a reference to the “daughters of
Jerusalem” (1:5). According to an ancient
teaching cited by the classical commentator,
Rashi, the “daughters of Jerusalem” are the
nations of the world. They are called the
daughters of Jerusalem, because in the
future, Jerusalem - the spiritual center of
Israel - will also be the spiritual center
for all the nations. Rashi adds that a
similar metaphor is found in the following
Divine promise to Jerusalem regarding the
nations of the world: “And I will give them
to you for daughters” (Ezekiel 16:61).
5. The above story about Rav Yosef Chaim
Sonnenfeld appears in the book “Guardian of
Jerusalem” - the Life and Times of Rabbi
Yosef Chaim Sonnenfeld. The author is Rabbi
Shlomo Zalman Sonnenfeld. Through this book,
I developed a deeper connection with Mother
Zion and all her children. For further
information on “Guardian of Jerusalem,”
visit:
http://www.artscroll.com/linker/hazon/ASIN/GUAH