If
the flowers fell out of the vase on Shabbos may one
return them?
One may not return flowers to water on
Shabbos even if they fell out on Shabbos.
On the other hand, one may return branches without
flowers to water on Shabbos.
The difference is that flowers bloom in water and
returning them causes the flowers to bloom, which is
similar to planting. It is unclear what the halacha
is when the flowers are already blooming and are open,
åö"ò, Sh’miras
Shabbos Kehilchasa 26 footnote 91.
May one add water
to the flower vase on Shabbos?
Chazal did not permit us to add water
to a vase on Shabbos and were even more stringent with
regards to changing the water. Both these actions are
prohibited on Shabbos on account of exerting oneself
unnecessarily on Shabbos. Therefore, if the vase is
nearly empty or it has a dirty color one may not add
water or change it.
One may add water to a vase on Yom Tov.
A guest arrives on
Shabbos (there is an eiruv) or on Yom Tov with a bunch
of flowers, may you put them in water?
As mentioned, flowers may never be placed in
water on Shabbos or Yom Tov due to their blooming. If
however the guests arrive with fragrant branches and the
like which do not have flowers, the halacha is
that one may not put
them in water on Shabbos and Yom Tov. One may instruct a
gentile to put them in a vase that has water prepared
before Shabbos.
|
Return flowers |
Return branches |
Put flowers or branches |
Add water |
Change water |
Shabbos |
ossur |
permitted |
ossur |
ossur |
Ossur |
Yom Tov |
ossur |
permitted |
ossur |
permitted |
Ossur |
May one remove an
avocado pit from water on Shabbos?
It is common to place an avocado pit into a
jar filled with water and watch it grow. It is forbidden
to remove the avocado pit from the water for the
following reasons: if the pit has already sprung roots,
the pit is considered as ‘planted’ in the water and
removing it would involve the melacha of
÷åöø – reaping; if
roots have not as yet sprung forth, because it was
placed in the water in order to grow, it is considered
‘planted’ and may not be removed from the water.
What difference
does it make whether there was intention to plant it or
not, isn’t it enough that it is in water to prohibit its
removal?
We find in the Shulchan Aruch
a case where people were accustomed to deposit fragrant
leaves in soil a day before Shabbos in order to keep
them fresh, with the intention of removing them on
Shabbos.
The
Shulchan Aruch rules that
they may be removed if 1) they have not yet
sprung roots and 2) if there was no intention
to plant them. The Mishna Berura
explains that when one intended to plant them and then
decides to remove them from the soil, one might not
realize that they have already sprung roots. Therefore
Chazal prohibited the removal of leaves, grains
etc. from soil (or water) when there was an intention to
plant them, even though they have not yet sprung roots.
The kitchen sink is
blocked! Is one permitted to use a plunger to unblock
it?
There are two ways to view this problem. One
way is to say that an entirely blocked drain or sink is
considered broken and therefore unblocking it
will be repairing, which is forbidden on Shabbos.
Another way is to say that it is not considered broken
as the pipes are merely blocked and unblocking the drain
is not called repairing the pipes.
Harav Moshe Feinstein ztz”l
is of the opinion that a (totally) blocked pipe is
comparable to not having a pipe at all and unblocking it
is like making a new opening. It is therefore ossur
to unblock. One may however instruct a gentile to
unblock it when very necessary.
Several other poskim share the same view as Rav
Moshe.
Rav
Shlomo Zalman Auerbach ztz”l
is of the opinion that we cannot say that the pipe is
non-existent, and therefore unblocking a blocked pipe is
not considered as repairing anything.
Being that it is a machlokes, one must ask for
rabbinical guidance in such an event.
May I pluck a hair
that is bothering me, from my head on Shabbos?
Cutting hair on Shabbos falls under the
umbrella of the melacha of
âåææ – shearing. The
Shulchan Aruch
teaches us that it is prohibited to cut or pluck hair,
whether one uses an instrument, such as scissors, or
one’s fingers.
There is a difference though as to the severity of the
action: one is only chayav (biblically
prohibited) when cutting hair with an instrument and
rabbinically prohibited when pulling out hair with one’s
fingers, in view of the fact that it is not the normal
manner for removing hair.
Another crucial issue is the number of hairs that need
to be cut. For one to violate an issur d’oraisso
(biblical prohibition) and be liable for the biblical
punishment, one would need to cut at least two
hairs. Although cutting a single hair is also an
issur d’oraisso
one is not subject to the punishment prescribed by the
Torah.
Consequently, pulling out even a single hair is an
issur d’rabanan (pulled out as opposed to cut) and
it may not be done on Shabbos.