May I reheat food by placing it on the radiators spread
around the house?
Yes you may
because it is not the normal cooking method.
It is comparable to placing cold food on top of a pot that
is already on the fire.
However, only dry, cooked food may be reheated; a liquid, or
a solid with gravy is forbidden to reheat.
What is the difference between
reheating a solid and a liquid?
Although
both are fully cooked, the halacha is that a cooked
solid may be reheated in the permitted manner because ein
bishul achar bishul (there is no re-cooking a solid). As
per liquids we say that yesh bishul achar bishul – a
cold liquid is prone to re-cooking. One of the reasons is
because heat is a major element of a liquid thus a cold
liquid is considered uncooked.
Is it permitted to steep cold,
cooked chicken inside cholent in my plate?
As far as
cooking goes, even if the chicken would reach the heat of
yad soledes bo
it is not a problem because as we said there is no
re-cooking a solid, but even as far as hatmana goes,
there is no issur to enwrap a food within a food.
As far as fully immersing a cooked egg within hot water a
shaila should be asked.
What is the halacha with regard to
immersing the kishke inside the cholent?
We find a
few opinions in the poskim regarding this matter. See
the footnote.
HaRav Shlomo Zalman Auerbach ztz”l held that it is
permitted since hatmana is usually done for the sake
of storing heat, and without enwrapping the food the heat
would be lost. Here the kishke is not enwrapped in
the cholent for the sake of storing heat; rather it is there
to get heated by the flame beneath the pot just as the
cholent is heated by the flames.
Others hold
that the kishke or rice should be slightly raised
above the cholent, which will satisfy all opinions.
Definitions
Before we
can deal with the following questions, these terms must be
defined:
A
k’li rishon (the first k’li) – the
cooking pot, whether on the fire or off, if it is yad
soledes bo it cooks whatever is placed inside.
A
k’li sheini – the
utensil into which the contents of a k’li rishon is
poured.
A
k’li shlishi – the
utensil into which the contents of a k’li sheini is
poured.
Is one permitted to put chalah or
matza into a plate of soup?
The problem
involved is bishul achar afiya – cooking after baking
or roasting. The Shulchan Aruch
mentions two opinions as to whether it is permitted to cook
a baked food and concludes that there are those who permit
it. Does the Mechaber mean that it is permitted even
in a k’li rishon (which is off the fire) or only in a
k’li sheini? It is a machlokes and one’s
Rav should be asked.
As for the
Rama, he says that the minhag is to be
stringent and bread should not be placed even inside a
k’li sheini.
The M”B
45 says that even though a ladle is classified l’chumra
as a k’li rishon, if the soup was served from the
k’li rishon with a ladle,
there is room for leniency and one may put bread and
matza into the plate.
Therefore
the answer is:
Sephardim should ask their Rav if bread may be put
into a k’li rishon or only into a k’li sheini.
Ashkenazim may only place bread in a k’li shlishi,
and in this instance a ladle is classed as a k’li sheini,
rendering the plate a k’li shlishi.
Accordingly, a biscuit may not be dunked into tea made in a
k’li sheini.
I like putting soup nuts (soup
almonds) in my soup, is there anything I must be aware of?
Soup nuts,
unlike bread, are fried, which is equivalent to cooking.
Since the halacha is that ein bishul achar bishul
– once a food has been cooked it is permitted to place it
again in a k’li rishon (that is off the fire), one
may add soup nuts to one’s soup. One may also put cooked
lokshen into a pot of boiling soup (that is off the
fire). Croutons however, are baked, and will have the same
rule as bread mentioned in the question above.
Is one permitted to make Nescafe in
a k’li sheini?
Nescafe, or
instant coffee, is first brewed and then either freeze dried
or spray dried. It should therefore be permitted to be put
even into a k’li rishon (off the fire) following the
above mentioned rule that it is permitted to cook a cooked
food. However, some poskim say a cooked soluble has a
status of a liquid and as such it is forbidden to re-cook
it. Therefore, the M”B
concludes that it should only be put into a k’li sheini
(although there are others who will only make it in a
k’li shlishi, for various reasons).