A
continuation of the laws pertaining to Amirah Le’akum,
instructing gentiles.
Is it permitted to
have a gentile turn on the air conditioning on Shabbos?
Preferably, the air conditioning should be
connected to a Shabbos clock, which would be timed to
turn the unit on and off. The question becomes pertinent
when there is no Shabbos clock as yet, or for some
reason it did not work and the air conditioning was not
turned on.
The
Mechaber
rules that in cold countries it is permitted to request
a gentile to turn on the heating for children and during
fierce cold weather it is even permitted to request a
gentile to turn on the heating for adults.
The
reason for this heter is because the cold can
make people sick and when illness is involved, one may
even request a gentile to violate an issur d’oraisso.
The question is:
can we compare severe cold to severe heat?
In so far as much as becoming ill because of
the severe heat, one can compare heat to cold, but if
the heat will merely cause discomfort, we cannot compare
the two.
In
other words, when the heat will distress a person so
much so that one might become bedridden, or cause
dehydration, or when it concerns old people or pregnant
women who might be affected by the heat, one may request
a gentile to turn on a fan or the air conditioning.
When
it will merely cause discomfort and weariness one may
not request a gentile to turn on the air conditioning.
What is the reason
for this restriction?
Moreinu the Chazon Ish ztz”l
ruled that the completing an electric circuit involves
an issur d’oraisso
of
Boneh (construction) and therefore turning on an
air conditioning or fan involves an issur d’oraisso.
The halacha is
that one may only request a gentile to violate an
issur d’oraisso
in
case of illness.
Does it make a
difference whether it is for personal use or in shul?
When the issue involves the public at large,
such as in shul, a dining room etc. there might be more
room for leniency, but a competent halachic
authority must be asked as to the correct conduct in
such an event.
It happened that a
gentile mistakenly removed the cholent from the stove on
Friday night and turned off the gas. When it was
realized that the food was for the morrow, the fire was
subsequently relit and the food returned. May it be
eaten?
The
problem in this case is that the gentile had violated an
issur d’oraisso
for
the sake of the Jew, besides the problem of chazora
– returning food to the fire.
The
Elya Raba
writes about a case where a gentile was about to improve
the light emanating from a lamp (which in certain cases
is a permitted action) and mistakenly extinguished the
lamp. He subsequently relit it and the question was
whether a Jew may benefit from this lamp. The Elya
Raba rules that one may benefit from this lamp
because it is considered as if the gentile lit it for
himself, in order to compensate for his mistake. The
halacha is that when we know that a gentile turned
on a light for his own benefit a Jew may benefit from
that light as well.
Accordingly, when the gentile made the mistake of
removing the food from the fire when he was not supposed
to, we can consider the entire episode of him relighting
the fire and returning the food as if he is doing it for
his own benefit to repair his error and the food is
permitted for consumption.
We
must add that this case has a plus to it in the fact
that the Jew would not have needed the gentile do the
issur for him had he not made the mistake in the
first place.
May one invite a
gentile on Shabbos to partake of the Shabbos meal?
It is permitted to invite a gentile to
partake of the Shabbos meal,
unlike Yom Tov, as we will see.
May one invite a
gentile on Yom Tov to eat at the Yom Tov table?
There definitely is a serious problem in
inviting a gentile, on Yom Tov, to partake of your Yom
Tov meal, for the following reasons:
The
possuk in (Sh’mos 12:17) states
àê àùø éàëì ìëì ðôù äåà ìáãå
éòùä ìëí, which teaches us that one may cook on
Yom Tov for the sake of Yom Tov. However, at the end of
the possuk the word ìëí
– for you, the gemora explains, means that one
may not cook or do any melacha for a gentile.
This means that one may cook and roast chicken for a Jew
on Yom Tov, but not for a gentile.
What could be
wrong, if for example the food is prepared in a single
pot?
Chazal prohibited preparing food for
a gentile on Yom Tov even though one is cooking it in
the same pot without any extra effort. The question
becomes more difficult when the Shulchan Aruch HaRav
points out that the halacha states that one may
fill a pot of water and boil it even though one only
needs the amount of one cup and the remainder will be
used after Yom Tov.
(One may not say that the excess is for after Yom
Tov and it may only be filled in one occurrence). If so,
why is it ossur to cook extra for a gentile even
though there is no extra effort invested?
The
answer is that when one invites a guest over to eat, one
makes sure that there is ample food for one’s household
and for the newly arrived guest. Chazal were
afraid that one would cook extra food for the
guest in a separate cooking pot and thus violate the
issur of cooking for a gentile. Therefore, even
though one does not intend to cook in a separate pot for
the gentile, there is reason for concern that it might
lead thereto.