(Permission is granted to print and redistribute this material
as long as this header and the footer at the end are included.)


ANSWERS TO REVIEW QUESTIONS

prepared by Rabbi Eliezer Chrysler
Kollel Iyun Hadaf, Jerusalem

Previous daf

Nazir 60

Questions

1)

(a) Our Mishnah (which prescribes a sixty-day period and a hundred and twenty-day period for a Nazir who is Tamei be'Safek and Muchlat be'Safek, is speaking about a short-term Nazir. The Tana of the Beraisa permits someone who is a Nazir for a year (under the same circumstances) ...
1. ... to eat Kodshim - after two years (one year in case he was just a Tahor Nazir, and a second year in case he was a Tamei Nazir).
2. ... to drink wine and become Tamei Meis - after four years for his Nezirus de'Tum'ah (in case he was a Muchlat, in which case the first two shavings were for his Tzara'as), and the fourth for his Nezirus de'Taharah.
(b) In any event, he will need to shave four times - at the end of two years and seven days later (for his Safek Tzara'as), at the end of three years (for his Safek Nezirus de'Tum'ah) and at the end of four years (for his Nezirus de'Taharah).

(c) When he shaves the first time, he brings the two birds (for his Safek Tzara'as and the Chatas ha'Of (for his Safek Nezirus de'Tum'ah in case he was not a Muchlat) and the Olas Beheimah (in case he was a Nazir Tahor). The Tana does not mention the Olas ha'Of, because, Chazal did not it seems, obligate him to bring it from a Safek (Tosfos).

(d) Despite the fact that a Metzora Muchlat needs to shave after seven days, he cannot shave immediately after thirty days - in case he a Nazir Tahor and not a Metzora Muchlat, who is forbidden to shave until the termination of his Nezirus.

2)
(a) With his second shaving - he brings the Chatas ha'Of (for his Safek Tzara'as) and the Olas Beheimah (for his Safek Nezirus de'Tum'ah, in case he was not a Muchlat).

(b) When he shaves the third time, he brings the Chatas ha'Of (for his Nezirus de'Tum'ah, in case he was a Muchlat) and the Olas Beheimah (for his Nezirus de'Taharah, in case he was a Metzora but not Tamei). With his fourth shaving - he brings his Korban Taharah (a lamb for an Olah, a ewe for a Chatas, and a ram for a Shelamim, in case he had been both a Muchlat and Tamei).

3)
(a) We learned that when he shaves the first time, he brings the two birds (for his Safek Tzara'as and the Chatas ha'Of (for his Safek Nezirus de'Tum'ah) and the Olas Beheimah (for his Safek Nezirus de'Taharah). The two birds are we referring to - are the birds brought by a Metzora Muchlat, one of which was Shechted and the other, sent away to the fields.

(b) What happens to the ...

1. Considering that he may be a Nazir Tahor, who does bring birds - the Chatas ha'Of (which is normally eaten by the Kohanim), has to be burned.
2. ... Olas ha'Of - is brought on condition that, should he be Tahor, it is a Nedavah.
(c) Even if he is not a Metzora, there is no problem with his bringing the two birds - seeing as they are not brought into the Azarah and they are not 'Chulin ba'Azarah'.

(d) On the assumption that he is a Muchlat or a Nazir Tamei, the Olas ha'Of is a Nedavah. He brings it however - in case he is a Nazir Tahor, who needs to bring one of his Korbanos in order to be able to shave).

4)
(a) A Metzora is also obligated to bring an Asham (without which he cannot eat Kodshim, which means that he must have brought his Asham, in order not to be a Mechusar Kipurim). The problem with bringing it is - that he will have to make a condition that, should he not be a Muchlat, it will be a Shelamim. Seeing as the latter can be eaten for two days and the former, only for one, this entails detracting from the days that one may eat a Shelamim (from two days to one, after which time it will have to be burned, and it is not permitted to create a situation whereby Kodshim may have to be burned).

(b) So we establish our Mishnah (which permits the Safek to eat Kodshim) like Rebbi Shimon - who permits making such a condition, because in his opinion, one may create a situation which whereby Kodshim may have to be burned.

60b---------------------------------------60b

Questions

5)

(a) 'Tamei Safek u'Muchlat Vaday, Ochel be'Kodshim le'Achar Shemonah Yamim' - meaning already from the eighth day.

(b) After shaving already on the first day, the procedure during the following week and on the eighth is - that he is sprinkled with the ashes of the Parah Adumah on the third and seventh days, and brings his Korbanos (Asham, Olah and Chatas) on the eighth.

(c) The basis for the radical difference between the case in our Mishnah and this case is - the fact that whereas Vaday Tzara'as overrides the prohibition for a Nazir to shave, Safek Tzara'as does not.

6)
(a) Seeing as he might be a Nazir Tahor however, it is not possible to shave immediately. Consequently - he performs his third shaving - on the thirty-first day from (and including) the eighth day (i.e. on the sixty-eighth day).

(b) He will be permitted to drink wine and become Tamei Meis - immediately after shaving.

(c) The order of precedence with regard to shaving, in the case of a Nazir who is Vaday Muchlat, Safek Tamei is - 1. Muchlat 2. Safek Tamei 2. Nazir Tahor.

7)
(a) 'Muchlat Safek ve'Tamei Vaday Ochel be'Kodshim le'Achar Sheloshim ve'Shiv'ah Yamim' He does not shave immediately in case he is not a Muchlat. So he brings his Korbanos for his Nezirus de'Tum'ah and shaves on the eighth day (after he has sprinkled on the third and the seventh days for his Nezirus de'Tum'ah).

(b) He will be permitted ...

1. ... to shave thirty days later (for his Safek Tzara'as), and to eat Kodshim on the following day (the thirty-eighth day).
2. ... to drink wine and become Tamei Meis - thirty-seven days later, seven days (incorporating the previous eighth day) when he shaves his third shaving (for the Nezirus de'Taharah to begin) and thirty days for his Nezirus de'Taharah (after seventy-four days).
(c) 'Tamei Vaday u'Muchlat Vaday Ochel be'Kodshim le'Achar Shemonah Yamim' - because a Vaday Muchlat is able to shave his first shaving immediately, his second one on the seventh day, enabling him to bring his Korbanos on the eighth and to eat Kodshim then, too (and *'le'Achar* Shemonah Yamim really means '*on* the eighth day').

(d) And he will be permitted to drink wine and to become Tamei Meis - on the forty-fifth day (after sprinkling on the following third and seventh days [for his Nezirus de'Tum'ah] and counting another thirty days [for his Nezirus de'Taharah]).

8)
(a) When they asked Rebbi Shimon bar Yochai whether a Nazir Tahor and Metzora Muchlat (before he has counted seven days) can get away with one shaving, he answered in the negative - because the Nazir shaves in order to remove his growth, whereas the Metzora shaves in order to grow it.

(b) He also answered in the negative with regard to a Nazir Tahor and the second shaving of a Muchlat (li'Yemei Sifro) despite the fact that the purpose of the latter too, is in order to remove the growth - because the shaving of the Metzora takes place (the day) before the sprinkling of the blood, whereas that of the Nazir takes place immediately afterwards.

(c) And the reason that he gave them as to why one shaving will not suffice for a Nazir Tamei who is also a Metzora (bi'Yemei Sifro), in spite of the fact that both shavings are in order to remove the hair, is - because the former takes place after he has Toveled, but the latter takes place before it.

Next daf

Index


For further information on
subscriptions, archives and sponsorships,
contact Kollel Iyun Hadaf,
daf@shemayisrael.co.il