POINT BY POINT SUMMARY
by Kollel Iyun Hadaf, Yerushalayim Rosh Kollel: Rabbi Mordecai Kornfeld
Ask A Question on the daf
Previous daf
Megilah 31
1) SPECIAL SEASONAL TORAH READINGS
(a) (Mishnah): On fast days, we read the blessings and curses;
(b) We do not interrupt the curses, one person reads them all.
(c) On Monday, Thursday and Shabbos afternoon we read from the
coming weekly Parsha;
(d) This does not count towards reading the Parsha, and the
entire Parsha is read the coming Shabbos.
(e) "And Moshe spoke the holidays of Hashem to Bnei Yisrael" -
that they should read about each holiday in its time.
(f) (Gemara - Beraisa): The Torah readings and Haftorahs for
the holidays are as follows:
1. Pesach - 1st day: the Parsha of the holidays; the
Haftorah is the Korban Pesach brought in Gilgal;
2. 2nd day: the Haftorah is the Pesach brought in the days
of Yoshiyahu.
3. Intermediate days: we read from various Parshas relating
to Pesach.
4. (Rav Papa): a mnemonic for them is MAFO (Mishchu, Im
Kesef, Pesal Lecha, va'Yedaber).
5. 7th day: "va'Yehi b'Shalach"; Haftorah - "va'Yedaber
David";
6. 8th day: "Kal ha'Bechor", and "Od ha'Yom".
i. (Abaye): Today the custom is to read on the 8
days: "Meshech, Tura, Kadesh, b'Kaspa, Pesal,
b'Madbera, Shelach, Buchra".
7. Shavuous: "7 weeks"; the Haftorah is in Chabakuk; others
say, "In the 3rd month", and the chariot (in
Yechezkel);
i. Today that we have 2 days of Yom Tov, we read as
the 2nd Tana says on the 1st day, and as the 1st
Tana says on the 2nd day.
8. Rosh Hashanah: "In the 7th month"; the Haftorah is
"ha'Ben Yakir Li"; others say, "And Hashem remembered
Sarah", the Haftorah is about Chana.
i. Today that we have 2 days of Yom Tov, we read as
the 2nd Tana says on the 1st day; on the 2nd day,
"And Hashem tested Avraham", and "ha'Ben Yakir
Li".
9. Yom Kipur: "After the death", and "So said the Exalted";
at Minchah we read the prohibitions of incest, and the
Haftorah is Sefer Yonah.
(g) R. Yochanan: Wherever Hashem's greatness is mentioned, his
humility is mentioned right after this - in Torah,
prophets, and Kesuvim.
1. In Torah - "Hashem is Lord of Lords ... and does justice
for orphans and widows".
2. In the prophets - "So says the Great and Exalted ... and
dwells with the afflicted and those of a low spirit."
3. In Kesuvim - "Praise He who rides on the deserts ... the
father of orphans and the judge of widows".
(h) Sukos: 1st day - the Parsha of the festivals; the Haftorah
is "A day is coming to Hashem".
(i) 2nd day: the same Torah reading, and "King Shlomo
gathered".
(j) The rest of Sukos: the Korbanos of each day.
(k) Shmini Atzeres: Mitzvahs, statutes and "Every firstborn";
the Haftorah is "When Shlomo finished"
(l) Simchas Torah: "And this is the blessing"; "And Shlomo
stood".
(m) (Rav Huna): The Shabbos of Chol ha'Moed (of both Pesach and
Sukos) we read "See, you say ...". On Pesach, the Haftorah
is "These dry bones"; on Sukos, "On the day Gog will come".
2) READINGS ON THE MINOR HOLIDAYS
(a) Chanukah: The (inauguration of the Mishkan by the) princes;
the Haftorah (on Shabbos) is the lamps in Zecharyah.
(b) If there is a 2nd Shabbos, its Haftorah is the lamps of
Shlomo.
(c) Purim: "And Amalek came".
(d) Rosh Chodesh: "On your Rosh Chodeshes"
(e) When Rosh Chodesh falls on Shabbos, the Haftorah is "And it
will be on every Rosh Chodesh".
(f) When Rosh Chodesh falls on Sunday, the Haftorah of the
previous day is "And Yonason said to him, tomorrow is Rosh
Chodesh".
31b---------------------------------------31b
(g) (Rav Huna): When Rosh Chodesh Av falls on Shabbos, the
Haftorah is "My soul abhors your Rosh Chodeshes and
festivals ...".
1. " ... They are a burden to me" - they force Hashem to
devise an appropriate punishment.
(h) (Rav): On Tisha b'Av, the Haftorah is "How did she become
as a harlot".
1. (Beraisa): Others say, the Torah reading is "If you will
not listen to me"; R. Nasan Bar Yosef says, "How long
will this nation despise me"; some say "How long for
this evil congregation".
2. (Abaye): The custom is to read "When you will have
children", and the Haftorah, "I will gather them".
3) MA'AMADOS
(a) (Mishnah): On Ma'amados we read about the creation of the
world.
(b) (R. Ami): Heaven and earth would not endure without the
merit of Ma'amados.
(c) Avraham asked Hashem: If Yisrael sins, will they be
destroyed or scattered? Hashem: No.
(d) Avraham: How can I know this? Hashem: Take for me a calf
... (sacrifices)
(e) Avraham: What will happen when there is no Beis ha'Mikdash?
Hashem: When they read the Parshas of sacrifices, I
consider it as if they offered them, and I will forgive
their sins.
4) BLESSINGS AND CURSES
(a) (Mishnah): On fast days we read blessings and curses; we do
not stop in the middle of the curses.
1. Question: Why not?
2. Answer#1 (R. Chiya Bar Gamda): "Do not despise the
rebuke of Hashem".
3. Answer#2 (Reish Lakish): We do not bless on punishments.
(b) (Beraisa): The one who reads the curses starts a verse
before them, and reads a verse after them.
1. (Abaye): This applies to the curses in Vayikra, but not
those in Devarim.
2.The former were said in the plural, by Hashem; the latter
were said in the singular, by Moshe.
(c) Levi Bar Buti was hurriedly rambling the curses in Devarim.
Rav Huna told him, he can stop in the middle.
(d) (Beraisa -R. Shimon Ben Elazar): Ezra enacted that we
should read the curses in Vayikra before Shavuous, and
those in Devarim before Rosh Hashanah.
1. (Abaye): This is so we should finish the year and its
curses.
2. Question: This does not explain those in Vayikra!
3. Answer: It does! - a Mishnah teaches that Shavuous is
also a new year - it is the judgment day for fruits.
(e) (Beraisa - R. Shimon Ben Elazar): If elders tell you to
destroy, and youths tell you to build, listen to the elders
- their destruction is building, and the building of youths
is destruction, as we see by Rechavam.
5) THE READING OF MONDAY, THURSDAY AND SHABBOS AFTERNOON
(a) (Beraisa - R. Meir): Each time we read the Torah (Shabbos
morning, Shabbos afternoon, Monday, and Thursday) we begin
reading where we stopped the previous time;
(b) R. Yehudah: Where we stop Shabbos morning, we begin Shabbos
afternoon, Monday, Thursday and the coming Shabbos morning.
(c) R. Zeira: The law is, where we stop Shabbos morning, we
begin Shabbos afternoon, Monday, Thursday and the coming
Shabbos morning.
(d) Question: Let him simply say, the law is as R. Yehudah!
(e) Answer: He had to say the law explicitly, since some learn
that the opinions of R. Meir and R. Yehudah are switched
(from our text of the Beraisa).
Next daf
|